The first version of the song released was a recording by Jerry Gray and his orchestra, released by Decca company in 1951, as catalog number 27621, with the flip side "Restringing the Pearls", by Skeets McDonald (released by Capitol Records as catalog number 1957, with the flip side "Be My Life's Companion").

A successful version of the song was recorded by Al Alberts' group, the Four Aces, on October 23, 1951, and released later the same year by Decca Records as catalog number 27860. It first reached the Billboard charts on September 7, 1951, and lasted 24 weeks on the chart, peaking at number two. The flip side was "A Garden in the Rain," also a success for the Aces.

It was also recorded a brief time later by Eddie Fisher in a version that scored the Top 10. This version was recorded on December 5, 1951, and released by RCA Victor Records as catalog number 20-4444. It first reached the Billboard charts on December 28, 1951 and lasted 19 weeks on the chart, peaking at number seven. The flip side featured the song "Trust in Me."

Bobby Vinton released "Tell Me Why" in 1964. Vinton's version spent eight weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 chart, peaking at number 13, while reaching number three on Billboard's Pop-Standards Singles chart, and number 11 on the Cash Box Top 100. In Canada, Vinton's version debuted at number 11 in the first issue of the RPM "Top Forty-5s" chart.

...
Wikipedia