Allan McGonigal (born 28 November 1964, in Stirling) is a Scottish former footballer and is the former manager of Scottish Third Division side Berwick Rangers.
As a player Allan was a striker with Meadowbank, Falkirk, Cowdenbeath, East Fife and East Stirlingshire. He was in the Meadowbank side that were runners-up to Accies in the First Division in 1987-88. Allan has also been assistant manager at Dumbarton, Forfar and Stenhousemuir.
Hamilton Accies announced on 24 June 2010 the appointment of McGonigal as their under-19 team manager.